The Next Phase of Online Media
Clay Shirky, professor of New Media and author of Here Comes Everybody, discusses the coming of the age of media patronage.
The Next Phase of Online Media
Question: What is the future of media?
If the economics of the old age don’t work as they don’t, what does work? And I think
we’re about to enter the second grade age of patronage. I don’t think that there are any
business models where customers pay directly or advertisers paid to interrupt. The
internet is just not good at either of those things and it’s very good at things that are in
competition with those models, but subsidy works fantastically well, right? So, in the
current Media Landscape, for instance on the radio dial, we regard a clear channel is the
norm and national public radio is the educators, right?
Advertisers pay the—it hit me with the idea that I should buy new flooring or car
insurance while I’m listening to classic rock. But the idea that 10% of the population
voluntarily gives money for something they could get for free, and then NPR takes that
money and makes great radio. That seems crazy on the radio dial, but on the internet, I
think those things are going to be reversed.
I think the idea that people get together in some subset of the most subsidize recreation of
something that anybody can have is actually an economic model that works better on the
internet than it does on the radio. And the clear channel model works worst on the
internet than it does in radio. So, I think, we’re entering this great age of media
patronage, and it will be interesting to see how that played at and it just especially
interesting now to think a lot of these small experiments in bits and pieces that you see
out there could go on to become the new normal as the as the Media Landscape
Question: What is your favorite new media model?
I since divided all media businesses up in the six boxes, right. There is user pace,
producer pace, and third party pace and there is required and optional and that’s it. All
business models right so I have to pay a dollar and fifty for the New York Times in the
newsstand that is required user pace plus there are ads in it which is required third party.
What the internet is done is it moved the line sharply over away from user pace and
towards third party pace or producer pace as move as sharply down from required to
optional. The business models that I think are interesting are the ones where you say, not
everybody has to pay, just enough people to pay for the business to work, right. The NPR
model we talking about earlier.
Meetup, the company that tries to get people to actually walk away from their computers
and go meet with one out there in the real world move to a four feet business model
because they realized that any third party they sold to would want to be able both
interrupt and distort the conversation people were having at the Meet Ups, and they said
look where here on behalf of the users. We have to charge the users. So there was this big
fight between essentially the board of directors and the board of advisers.
And the question was, “Do you charge the individual participants or do you charge the
groups?” And ultimately at the end of this conversation we came up with the idea of
charging the groups because each group can say the leader of the group is going to be a
mocker and pay $9 a month on their own and they collect in social capital what they
spent in physical capital. Or if it’s a restaurant going group everybody just kicks in buck
after the meal and then it works out if not like the fee or the regulars pay but the
newcomers don’t then they decided to join.
Different groups can collect the money in different ways and Meetup doesn’t have to
care. And that ability to say essentially here the minimum requirements for this business
model but the users are actually going to find a better way of partialing out the problem
of how do you come out with 9 bucks a month than we are. That seems to me be a way to
take the logic of crowd sourcing and apply it to the business model which is around
certain minimum constraint. You just let people work it out on their own on the outside.
So there are going to be lots and lots of experiments. Some of them are working in some
environment, you reference to Daily Biz and obviously having to post and so forth, and
then there’s not going to be anyone general business model. I think we will look back 20
years from now and we will laugh that we ever thought the New York Times and the
Daily Racing form were in the same business right. It’s just because they are both on
printing press. Like clearly sports betting information is going to go the one corner of the
Global news guides was just going to go to another corner, and the idea that the fact that
they appeared on paper made them the same somehow is going to seem ridiculous to us
because there’s no one business model that replaces paper. It’s —once the paper is going
as the lynch pen all of these businesses kind of migrate to some natural place to exist and
including for a lot of businesses the natural place to exist is if there’s no inefficiency for
print you go out of business and so that’s the—it’s really the places like Meetup that have
the business models that are fluid enough that they’re constantly learning what works
rather than just transitioning from A to B. I’ve been most interest to that.
Question: What companies understand social media well?
One of the really exemplary stories of the difference between assuming the audience is
yours and assuming the audience is out there comes from TimesSelect. The New York
Times’ attempt, in fact, not just attempt the New York Times’ decision took put up a pay
They put up a pay wall in May of 2005 something like that, yeah, back in 2005 and
started charging for everything and of course traffic plummeted and then they took it
down, I guess, in 2007 and Saul Berger the publisher The Times just recently said, “The
reason we took down TimesSelect was we hadn’t anticipated how much traffic would
come from search.”
And so, first of all, there’s the CEO of a major newspaper who didn’t think that search
was going to be important source of readers, but having realized that they changed their
strategy because they understood that there were people out there working to send them
readers, were spending their own money to send the New York Times additional readers
for free. And that their business model ought to be able to take advantage of that free
sense of that free traffic. The question of analog times and digital dollars then kicks in
right how do you restructure the paper to take advantage of digital advertising?
But it’s an example of a restructuring that says, “We thought the audience was this one
way or in this one place.”
And then we realize no, actually they’re over here, right they are coming from Google.
To a degree that it would be hard to overstate Google as the New York Times’ front page
and for increasing over business obviously it is, and they restructure their business to take
advantage of that as well. Certainly in the creative industries there’s lots and lots of these
The replacement of the music A&R Department with MySpace like the breakout of
Soulja Boy Tell ‘Em and Crank that as a song that everybody discovered, but no one
anointed that’s a really interesting case where their businesses able to now…it’s actually
get free focus group style research of much higher quality than doing regular music
focused group sampling, and it cost them nothing and then they can sign Soulja Boy Tell
‘Em. So, with that’s another business where the presence of social network is actually
creating an ultimate way to decide what it is the business should be concentrating or
licensing or turning into a commercial product.
The Next Phase of Online Media
Even if you don\'t know what automated solid phase extraction is, you could work in a job one day which requires you to hire the services of a company that offer the service. If you are unsure about automated solid phase extraction how do you go about finding a company that can help you out?...
It is very important to realize that admitting or recognizing the grief promotes its healing process....
Globally, the osteoporosis market displayed a 3.5% compound annual growth rate (CAGR) between 2005–09, reaching $9.4 billion in 2009....
There are various phases that includes in web application development. Each step should be studies thoroughly before proceeding towards actual implementation....
I recently scan the book titled, The law of attraction, by Jerry and Esther Hicks. It's a terribly powerful book because it goes into details on how to use the law of attraction to your life and answers questions I've got heard a lot of folks raise concerning the law of attraction. In this book they really cover many completely different laws and tips that create up the overall law of attraction and one I found significantly useful is termed Section Intending....
According to people in the wellness centers wearing lab coat, cancer patients are being recommended to go to spa for a massage treatment because they usually suffer from constipation. Constipation is caused by chemotherapy for cancer patients. Going to spa or massage parlor is a caprice to some but to cancer patients, it is more of a necessity rather than as a mere whim....
Media is mode of communication which helps to transfer the information, whereas media buying is a mode of advertising through some popular means of media. Media buying is all about purchasing the adve......
When you undertake Six Sigma initiatives, you need to know how well your project is progressing. You also need to know where you stand in comparison to others - where you rate as to top standards and best practices set by other companies. These are the external references with which you base an assessment of your achievements. This is nothing but benchmarking....
Metrics are the ones that remind us that there is a need to measure the important aspects in our business; otherwise, there is a great chance that we will not be able to achieve our goals. No matter what area in your company you would like to start the metrics development particularly for the product metrics, there is a need to undergo a process that is quite challenging....
Pokemon games are video series inspired by the cartoons that still are very popular. They were created by Nintendo and appeared for the first time in1996 in Japan and in less than a year the game was known all over the world. The games are usually coming in pairs, and after the digital games that are being released, puzzles are created and even action role-playing or pets. The second generatio